HomePoliticsThe West Is Not Being Conquered, It Is Vacating Everything It Built

The West Is Not Being Conquered, It Is Vacating Everything It Built

These ideas [from the Bible]… are what built the West. The Magna Carta, the common-law tradition, the American founding documents, the very notion of rights that precede the state — all draw from that shared scriptural source. The long record of Jewish exclusion does not disprove the lineage; it shows how imperfectly Christian societies lived up to the standards they inherited from the Bible.

The same country, Italy, that once exported the idea of citizenship under law is today importing parallel legal orders whose authority is not contractual but scriptural.

The emptying of churches did not produce a neutral public square. It produced a vacuum of conviction that has been filled, in the major cities of Western Europe, by a religion that has never accepted the secular bargain and we know which one. Fertility rates tell the story more clearly than any manifesto…. The result is not “diversity” in the abstract; it is the progressive Islamization of neighborhoods, schools, and soon electoral districts.

Islam’s strength, the author Michel Onfray observed, is the direct consequence of Christianity’s weakness. Where the churches emptied, the mosques filled. Where the language of original sin and personal responsibility was discarded, the language of collective grievance and religious entitlement took its place.

This is not a “conspiracy theory;” it is arithmetic plus ideology. A society that no longer believes its own founding stories will not transmit them. A society that no longer reproduces will be replaced by one that does. The “ethnic and religious change” is therefore not an accident of migration policy. It is the demographic consequence of a prior abdication. The West is not being conquered so much as it is vacating everything it built.

In Italy, the Muslim population remains smaller than in France, Belgium or Sweden, but the same patterns are visible: higher Muslim fertility rates, parallel social norms in certain neighborhoods, and a growing capacity to extract concessions….

Qatar, Turkey and the Gulf states continue to finance mosques and cultural centers whose explicit purpose is to shape European Muslim communities toward political Islam. Italy has not systematically restricted that funding, nor has it treated the Muslim Brotherhood networks operating under the cover of civil society as the strategic problem they are.

Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni’s administration is constrained by European law, by coalition politics, and by an administrative state still shaped by the multicultural assumptions of the 1990s and 2000s. It can slow the flow; it cannot reverse the settlement that has already occurred.

Russia’s foreign policy has repeatedly aligned with actors — Iran, Hezbollah, Assad’s Syria — that treat Israel as an illegitimate outpost. An alliance whose purpose is to defend a liberal, democratic, Judeo-Christian heritage definitely does not need a partner that rejects European values, represses independent churches, and treats international law as a tool of convenience.

Russia’s claim to be the last Christian power is just a geopolitical maneuver not a shared civilizational commitment. Israel, the United States, and the remaining Western governments that still regard free speech, equality under law, and the legitimacy of the Jewish state as non-negotiable can build a great alliance without Moscow.

Giulio Meotti, a journalist and commentator, is based in Rome, Italy,

Grégoire Canlorbe: You refer to the West as built on “Judeo-Christian values.” Does that still exist?

Giulio Meotti: The claim that “Judeo-Christianity” does not exist is a fashionable academic conceit that collapses under historical and civilizational scrutiny. Judaism and Christianity have profound theological disagreements — on the messiah, the Trinity, the status of the Law. Catholic Europe subjected Jews to expulsions, ghettos, blood libels and worse. The term does not erase that history. The two traditions share the same foundational text, the Hebrew Bible. They produced the same moral grammar: the dignity of the individual created in the image of God, the distinction between legitimate authority and arbitrary power, the idea that rulers are accountable to a law higher than themselves.

These ideas, not the later schisms, are what built the West. The Magna Carta, the common-law tradition, the American founding documents, the very notion of rights that precede the state — all draw from that shared scriptural source. The long record of Jewish exclusion does not disprove the lineage; it shows how imperfectly Christian societies lived up to the standards they inherited from the Bible. The same societies that persecuted Jews also produced the legal and cultural space in which Jews could eventually be emancipated and, later, in which Israel could be defended as a legitimate national project.

Today the term is attacked not because of historical precision but because it is the last remaining barrier against the claim that the West is merely one of many value systems. Erase “Judeo-Christian,” and the West becomes just one more cultural formation among others, open to replacement by any higher-fertility, higher-conviction ideology. That is the real stake. The theological disagreements remain; the civilizational debt does not.

Canlorbe: How do you assess the historical importance of Italy in shaping the principles of freedom and rule of law?

Meotti: Italy’s contribution to the principles of freedom and the rule of law is immense. Ancient Rome did not invent abstract “rights,” but it did invent the institutional machinery that made them conceivable: a written law that applied, at least in theory, to citizens and non-citizens alike; the separation of public office from private wealth; the idea that authority was delegated and could be revoked. The Roman concept of res publica — the public thing — survived the fall of the empire and reappeared whenever Europeans wanted to limit arbitrary power.

The Medieval and Renaissance republics refined that inheritance. Florence’s republican experiments, for all their oligarchic limits, treated political life as an art of balancing competing interests under law rather than under the will of one person, whether religiously or by heredity. Venice’s centuries-long stability rested on elaborate constitutional checks, term limits, and a mercantile culture that prized contracts over personal status. These were not liberal democracies, but they kept alive the possibility that political order could be designed rather than simply inherited or “revealed.”

That Italian tradition is now almost unrecognizable in the peninsula that produced it. The same country, Italy, that once exported the idea of citizenship under law is today importing parallel legal orders whose authority is not contractual but scriptural. The historical irony is brutal: the heirs of Rome and Florence are losing the very capacity to maintain a single public law. If Italy cannot recover the institutional habits that once made its city-states and its empire the models of ordered liberty, the rest of Europe will have even less reason to believe those habits can be defended.

Canlorbe: Do you see a change from secularization to religion in the West?

Meotti: Yes, secularization and the religious transformation of the West are not parallel processes; they are sequential. The emptying of churches did not produce a neutral public square. It produced a vacuum of conviction that has been filled, in the major cities of Western Europe, by a religion that has never accepted the secular bargain and we know which one. Fertility rates tell the story more clearly than any manifesto. Native European populations have been below replacement for half a century; Muslim communities have maintained rates that double or triple that figure. The result is not “diversity” in the abstract; it is the progressive Islamization of neighborhoods, schools, and soon electoral districts.

The elites who accelerated secularization imagined that the loss of Christian belief would liberate individuals. Instead, it liberated the expansion of the most demographically assertive and theologically self-confident populations. Islam’s strength, the author Michel Onfray observed, is the direct consequence of Christianity’s weakness. Where the churches emptied, the mosques filled. Where the language of original sin and personal responsibility was discarded, the language of collective grievance and religious entitlement took its place.

This is not a “conspiracy theory;” it is arithmetic plus ideology. A society that no longer believes its own founding stories will not transmit them. A society that no longer reproduces will be replaced by one that does. The “ethnic and religious change” is therefore not an accident of migration policy. It is the demographic consequence of a prior abdication. The West is not being conquered so much as it is vacating everything it built.

Canlorbe: Do you think that the current Italian administration is up to the challenges that the domestic and foreign Islamic threats are posing to Italy and, generally speaking, the West?

Meotti: The current government has altered the tone and the border policy; it has not yet altered the underlying trajectory. Italy’s naval operations and the Albania processing centers have reduced arrivals compared to the open-door years, and Italy’s rhetoric no longer treats every irregular migrant as a potential citizen. It is a huge improvement over the previous decade. It is not, however, a strategic answer to the challenge from Islam both inside the country and abroad.

In Italy, the Muslim population remains smaller than in France, Belgium or Sweden, but the same patterns are visible: higher Muslim fertility rates, parallel social norms in certain neighborhoods, and a growing capacity to extract concessions on schools, halal food, and public spaces.

Foreign policy is more decisive. Qatar, Turkey and the Gulf states continue to finance mosques and cultural centers whose explicit purpose is to shape European Muslim communities toward political Islam. Italy has not systematically restricted that funding, nor has it treated the Muslim Brotherhood networks operating under the cover of civil society as the strategic problem they are.

Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni’s administration is constrained by European law, by coalition politics, and by an administrative state still shaped by the multicultural assumptions of the 1990s and 2000s. It can slow the flow; it cannot reverse the settlement that has already occurred. Whether it is “up to the challenges” will be measured not by the number of boats turned back in a given year, but by whether Italy still possesses a single legal and cultural order in 2040. On that metric the evidence remains thin.

Canlorbe: You have been calling for a “global alliance for Western values, with Israel at its heart.” Do you believe Russia should join such an alliance?

Meotti: A “global alliance for Western values with Israel at its heart” cannot include Russia under its present regime. Putin’s government presents itself as the defender of Christian civilization against Western decadence, and the Orthodox Church under Kirill has become an instrument of that claim. The rhetoric is effective precisely because large parts of Western Europe have abandoned any public Christian identity. Yet the same regime that denounces gender ideology and multiculturalism is conducting a war of conquest in Ukraine, maintains strategic ties with Iran, and oversees a domestic Muslim population whose growth it cannot reverse.

Russia’s demographic trajectory mirrors, on a smaller scale, the problem we have in the West: low fertility and higher rates among Muslim minorities — mainly in the Caucasus and among Central Asian migrants. Russia’s foreign policy has repeatedly aligned with actors — Iran, Hezbollah, Assad’s Syria — that treat Israel as an illegitimate outpost. An alliance whose purpose is to defend a liberal, democratic, Judeo-Christian heritage definitely does not need a partner that rejects European values, represses independent churches, and treats international law as a tool of convenience.

Eastern European states have wisely resisted mass migration and retained a clearer national and Christian identity. Russia’s claim to be the last Christian power is just a geopolitical maneuver not a shared civilizational commitment. Israel, the United States, and the remaining Western governments that still regard free speech, equality under law, and the legitimacy of the Jewish state as non-negotiable can build a great alliance without Moscow.

 egretnewseditor@gmail.com 

RELATED ARTICLES
- Advertisment -
Google search engine

Most Popular

Recent Comments